Indeed vs Totaljobs vs Reed vs Caterer.com: which is cheapest?
Reed’s new-customer ad (£89 + VAT) is the cheapest published single ad; Totaljobs and Caterer.com share one price list (£220 after a £69 first ad); Indeed publishes no price. Instead beats all four: free to post, £39 a hire.
By Elliott Gibb, founder of Instead and director of Monty Ventures Limited. Last updated 5 November 2026.
| Published price | When you pay | 3 hires a year | Reach | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Instead | Free to post. First hire free, then £39 a hire. | Only when you mark someone hired. Waived if they don’t start within 30 days. | £78First hire free, then 2 × £39. | Your staff, regulars, followers and past applicants first; then a public job page, Google for Jobs and local area pages. |
| Indeed | Free listing (3 a month, 30 days each); sponsored jobs on a budget you set, no price published | Before anyone is hired: every click or started application counts, hire or not | Unknown up frontIndeed publishes no price per click or per application in the UK. The minimum appears only on the sponsorship screen. Free jobs fall back in search as newer ones arrive. | National. The largest UK job seeker audience of any board. |
| Totaljobs | Pro job ad £220 for 30 days (£69 new-customer price). Pro Plus £275. Pro Ultimate £352 for 60 days. | Before anyone applies | £509 to £660One Pro ad per hire: £69 for the first (new-customer price), £220 each after: £69 + £220 + £220 = £509. At the list price, 3 × £220 = £660. VAT not stated on the page. | National, all industries. |
| Caterer.com | “Post your first job for £69.” After that, Pro £220 for 30 days, Pro Plus £275, Pro Ultimate £352 for 60 days. | Before anyone applies | £509 to £660One Pro ad per hire: £69 + £220 + £220 = £509 with the first-job offer, 3 × £220 = £660 without. VAT not stated. | Hospitality workers across the UK. |
| Reed | Job ads from £89 + VAT (new-customer price, live up to 6 weeks). Monthly plans from £125 a month. Boosts £225 to £599 + VAT. | Before anyone is hired | £267 + VAT at leastThree Premium ads at the new-customer price: 3 × £89 = £267 + VAT. Reed doesn’t show the price after the offer on the page we read. | National, all industries. Reed also runs a recruitment agency. |
| CV-Library | Single 28-day ad £149 + VAT (£75 + VAT for new customers); two ads £129 + VAT. CV search sold separately. | Before anyone applies | £373 to £447 + VATOne ad per hire: £75 + £149 + £149 = £373 + VAT with the new-customer price, 3 × £149 = £447 + VAT without. | National, all industries. |
Are Totaljobs and Caterer.com the same price?
Yes. Both show the same products at the same prices: Pro £220, Pro Plus £275, Pro Ultimate £352, each with a new-customer price.
Is Indeed cheaper than Totaljobs?
It can be, because you set the budget. It can also cost more, because you pay per click or started application until you hire, and Indeed publishes no UK price to check against.
What do all four have in common?
They all charge before you hire. Instead is the only option here that charges nothing until you mark someone hired.
Instead against the rest
- Instead vs IndeedIndeed alternatives
- Instead vs TotaljobsTotaljobs alternatives
- Instead vs Caterer.comCaterer.com alternatives
- Instead vs ReedReed alternatives
- Instead vs CV-LibraryCV-Library alternatives
- Instead vs Job TodayJob Today alternatives
- Instead vs HarriHarri alternatives
- Instead vs CoopleCoople alternatives
- Instead vs Find a Job (GOV.UK)Find a Job (GOV.UK) alternatives
- Instead vs Recruitment agenciesRecruitment agencies alternatives
Sources
- Indeed: How pricing works (updated 30 Sept 2026), read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: pay per started application, read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: free job post limit, read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: invoices and charge threshold, read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: close or pause a job, read 5 November 2026.
- Totaljobs: single job ads, read 5 November 2026.
- Caterer.com: single job ads, read 5 November 2026.
- Reed: for recruiters, read 5 November 2026.
- Reed: post a job, read 5 November 2026.
- Reed: pay per application, read 5 November 2026.
- 100Hires: best UK job boards for employers (Jul 2026), read 5 November 2026 (a third party’s report, not the company’s own page).
Prices change and new-customer offers come and go. If a number here is out of date, email hello@instead.work and it’s fixed the same day.