The job board tax
Job boards sell strangers. They are paid for your search, not your hire. Every advert, click and started application is billed whether or not anyone gets the job, so the longer you search, the more they earn. Instead is paid only when you hire: £39.
By Elliott Gibb, founder of Instead and director of Monty Ventures Limited. Last updated 5 November 2026.
What is the job board tax?
The job board tax is what a small business pays a job board before it hires anyone: per advert, per click, per application or per month, the same whether the job is filled or not.
Indeed’s own pricing page puts it plainly: “You incur charges when somebody interacts with your job post.” Not when you hire. Totaljobs and Caterer.com take £220 up front for 30 days. Reed takes £89 + VAT and up. Job Today takes a subscription. None of them is paid to fill your job.
Who are job boards really built for?
Agencies and chains. Of 668 hospitality job ads we read on Reed across 14 UK cities on 4 and 5 November 2026, 20 (3%) were posted under a name that could be an independent café, pub or restaurant. The rest came from recruitment agencies, chains, hotel groups, contract caterers and other employers.
An independent café pays the same £220 as a hotel group, and competes with every agency for the same applicants. The boards are priced for the businesses that buy ads every week. You hire twice a year.
Why do job boards send so many wrong applicants?
Because volume is what they sell. A board paid per click or per started application earns more from more applications, whether or not any of them is right for you.
“We have received very few enquiries for the actual chef position”
“Wasted over £150 no qualified candidate.”
“Get swamped with unfiltered unsuitable applicants”
Why do candidates never hear back?
Because the board buries every employer in applications they can’t answer. UK job seekers don’t hear back from 55% of the jobs they apply for, and 86% would rather get a no than hear nothing (Indeed’s own research, May 2024).
“Applied for 28 jobs after being made redundant, and only received communication of any form from 5 of them.”
“Even following an interview they don't bother to let you know you have been unsuccessful.”
On Instead, every candidate hears back within 48 hours: the owner is reminded at 24 and 36 hours, and anyone still waiting gets an honest “you’re on our bench” reply. Never a fake rejection.
What does the job board tax cost a small business?
About £509 to £660 a year for three hires on Totaljobs or Caterer.com at published prices, more through an agency, and an unknown amount on Indeed. On Instead, £78.
| Published price | When you pay | 3 hires a year | Reach | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Instead | Free to post. First hire free, then £39 a hire. | Only when you mark someone hired. Waived if they don’t start within 30 days. | £78First hire free, then 2 × £39. | Your staff, regulars, followers and past applicants first; then a public job page, Google for Jobs and local area pages. |
| Indeed | Free listing (3 a month, 30 days each); sponsored jobs on a budget you set, no price published | Before anyone is hired: every click or started application counts, hire or not | Unknown up frontIndeed publishes no price per click or per application in the UK. The minimum appears only on the sponsorship screen. Free jobs fall back in search as newer ones arrive. | National. The largest UK job seeker audience of any board. |
| Totaljobs | Pro job ad £220 for 30 days (£69 new-customer price). Pro Plus £275. Pro Ultimate £352 for 60 days. | Before anyone applies | £509 to £660One Pro ad per hire: £69 for the first (new-customer price), £220 each after: £69 + £220 + £220 = £509. At the list price, 3 × £220 = £660. VAT not stated on the page. | National, all industries. |
| Caterer.com | “Post your first job for £69.” After that, Pro £220 for 30 days, Pro Plus £275, Pro Ultimate £352 for 60 days. | Before anyone applies | £509 to £660One Pro ad per hire: £69 + £220 + £220 = £509 with the first-job offer, 3 × £220 = £660 without. VAT not stated. | Hospitality workers across the UK. |
| Reed | Job ads from £89 + VAT (new-customer price, live up to 6 weeks). Monthly plans from £125 a month. Boosts £225 to £599 + VAT. | Before anyone is hired | £267 + VAT at leastThree Premium ads at the new-customer price: 3 × £89 = £267 + VAT. Reed doesn’t show the price after the offer on the page we read. | National, all industries. Reed also runs a recruitment agency. |
| Recruitment agencies | Typically 15% to 30% of the first year’s salary per permanent hire | When you hire, but a share of salary, not a fixed fee | £11,250 to £22,500Three hires at £25,000 a year (a chef, say), at 15% to 30%: £3,750 to £7,500 each. | The agency’s own list of candidates. |
How do you stop paying it?
Hire from the people who already know you first: staff, regulars, followers, past applicants. Instead does that free and charges £39 only when you hire.
We call it network-first hiring. The people who already chose your business (the ones who drink your coffee, follow your Instagram and work your Saturdays) are better candidates than strangers who clicked a button, and asking them costs nothing. A job board is the last resort, not the first move. How to stop Indeed charging you.
Instead against the rest
- Instead vs IndeedIndeed alternatives
- Instead vs TotaljobsTotaljobs alternatives
- Instead vs Caterer.comCaterer.com alternatives
- Instead vs ReedReed alternatives
- Instead vs CV-LibraryCV-Library alternatives
- Instead vs Job TodayJob Today alternatives
- Instead vs HarriHarri alternatives
- Instead vs CoopleCoople alternatives
- Instead vs Find a Job (GOV.UK)Find a Job (GOV.UK) alternatives
- Instead vs Recruitment agenciesRecruitment agencies alternatives
Sources
- Indeed: How pricing works (updated 30 Sept 2026), read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: pay per started application, read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: free job post limit, read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: invoices and charge threshold, read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: close or pause a job, read 5 November 2026.
- Trustpilot reviews of uk.indeed.com, read 5 November 2026.
- Totaljobs: single job ads, read 5 November 2026.
- Trustpilot reviews of www.totaljobs.com, read 5 November 2026.
- Caterer.com: single job ads, read 5 November 2026.
- Reed: for recruiters, read 5 November 2026.
- Reed: post a job, read 5 November 2026.
- Reed: pay per application, read 5 November 2026.
- Trustpilot reviews of www.reed.co.uk, read 5 November 2026.
- 100Hires: best UK job boards for employers (Jul 2026), read 5 November 2026 (a third party’s report, not the company’s own page).
- Betterteam: Job Today (UK), read 5 November 2026 (a third party’s report, not the company’s own page).
- Harri: pricing, read 5 November 2026.
- Coople UK: pricing, read 5 November 2026.
- Find a Job: for employers, read 5 November 2026.
- Agency Central: how recruitment agencies get paid, read 5 November 2026 (a third party’s report, not the company’s own page).
- HR Grapevine: Brits don’t hear back from more than half the jobs they apply for, read 5 November 2026 (a third party’s report, not the company’s own page).
Prices change and new-customer offers come and go. If a number here is out of date, email hello@instead.work and it’s fixed the same day.