Instead vs Indeed
Indeed is paid when someone clicks or starts an application, not when you hire, so its money comes in whether or not your job gets filled. Instead (instead.work), the UK hiring tool, is free to post and charges £39 only when you hire, with the first hire free.
By Elliott Gibb, founder of Instead and director of Monty Ventures Limited. Last updated 5 November 2026.
| Published price | When you pay | 3 hires a year | Reach | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Instead | Free to post. First hire free, then £39 a hire. | Only when you mark someone hired. Waived if they don’t start within 30 days. | £78First hire free, then 2 × £39. | Your staff, regulars, followers and past applicants first; then a public job page, Google for Jobs and local area pages. |
| Indeed | Free listing (3 a month, 30 days each); sponsored jobs on a budget you set, no price published | Before anyone is hired: every click or started application counts, hire or not | Unknown up frontIndeed publishes no price per click or per application in the UK. The minimum appears only on the sponsorship screen. Free jobs fall back in search as newer ones arrive. | National. The largest UK job seeker audience of any board. |
What is the difference between Instead and Indeed?
Indeed charges before anyone is hired: every click or started application counts, hire or not. Instead charges nothing until you mark someone hired, then £39, and the first hire is free.
That’s the whole argument. Indeed is paid for the search; Instead is paid for the hire. When the search drags on, one of them earns more and the other earns nothing, and you should know which side each is on. Instead hires from the people who already know your business first: network-first hiring.
How much does Indeed cost?
Free listing (3 a month, 30 days each); sponsored jobs on a budget you set, no price published. Billing: per click or per started application, invoiced on the 1st of the month or when your spend reaches £500 (read 5 November 2026).
- Indeed’s own pricing page: “There is no flat upfront fee to post a job on Indeed.” Sponsored jobs are charged “per click or per started application, depending on the budget type and market.”
- Its help centre says qualifying jobs are put on pay per started application automatically: “You cannot switch back to pay-per-click.”
- Free jobs: up to 3 a calendar month, shared across every location of the same company, each shown for up to 30 days. Indeed says free listings “fall back in search as new jobs are added over time”.
- Billing: invoiced on the 1st of the month, or as soon as your balance reaches £500 on a card. Closing a job mid-month still means an invoice the following month.
- Downgrading a sponsored job to free: “you may still incur remaining charges for billable activity”, up to your maximum budget.
- New UK accounts get a £100 credit to sponsor their first job, which expires a year after the account is made. After that you’re charged your sponsored budget.
Three hires a year on Indeed: Unknown up front. Indeed publishes no price per click or per application in the UK. The minimum appears only on the sponsorship screen. Free jobs fall back in search as newer ones arrive. On Instead: £78 (first hire free, then 2 × £39).
What’s wrong with Indeed?
Indeed is paid when someone clicks or starts an application, not when you hire, so its money comes in whether or not your job gets filled.
What owners and job seekers say about Indeed, in their own words:
“We have received very few enquiries for the actual chef position”
“Wasted over £150 no qualified candidate.”
“Get swamped with unfiltered unsuitable applicants”
“there's no real way to escalate when this happens”
“Even following an interview they don't bother to let you know you have been unsuccessful.”
Trustpilot doesn’t verify reviews and 1-star pages are self-selected: this shows what hurts, not how often.
Is Indeed ever better than Instead?
Yes. Reach. If you need hundreds of applications for a role nobody near you wants, nobody beats Indeed’s audience. Use it for: businesses hiring at volume, or for roles where the right person isn’t anywhere near your network.
Can I use Instead and Indeed together?
Yes. Posting on Instead costs nothing, so share the job with your staff, regulars and followers first, and pay Indeed only if that isn’t enough.
Looking for something else? The best Indeed alternatives, ranked.
Instead against the rest
- Instead vs TotaljobsTotaljobs alternatives
- Instead vs Caterer.comCaterer.com alternatives
- Instead vs ReedReed alternatives
- Instead vs CV-LibraryCV-Library alternatives
- Instead vs Job TodayJob Today alternatives
- Instead vs HarriHarri alternatives
- Instead vs CoopleCoople alternatives
- Instead vs Find a Job (GOV.UK)Find a Job (GOV.UK) alternatives
- Instead vs Recruitment agenciesRecruitment agencies alternatives
Sources
- Indeed: How pricing works (updated 30 Sept 2026), read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: pay per started application, read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: free job post limit, read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: invoices and charge threshold, read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: close or pause a job, read 5 November 2026.
- Trustpilot reviews of uk.indeed.com, read 5 November 2026.
- Instead: facts and prices, read 5 November 2026.
Prices change and new-customer offers come and go. If a number here is out of date, email hello@instead.work and it’s fixed the same day.