Is Indeed worth it for a small business?
For most small cafés, pubs and shops, no: Indeed charges for clicks and started applications, not hires, and owners report piles of unsuitable applicants. It’s worth it for roles your own network can’t fill. Instead charges £39 per hire.
By Elliott Gibb, founder of Instead and director of Monty Ventures Limited. Last updated 5 November 2026.
When is Indeed worth it?
When you need volume or reach: a hard-to-fill role, a new site with no regulars yet, or dozens of hires at once. Nothing in the UK has a bigger audience.
When is Indeed not worth it?
When the right person is already near you. A weekend barista, a kitchen porter, Christmas cover: paying per click to reach strangers nationally is the slowest, most expensive way to find someone local.
Owners on Trustpilot: “Wasted over £150 no qualified candidate.” “Get swamped with unfiltered unsuitable applicants.” One chef vacancy drew builders: “We have received very few enquiries for the actual chef position” (3 Nov 2026).
Why does Indeed send so many unsuitable applicants?
Because Indeed is paid per click or per started application. More applications means more revenue, whether or not any of them are right for you.
What should a small business use instead?
Its own network. Instead sends the job to your staff, regulars and followers first, reads every application against your must-haves and charges £39 only when you hire.
Instead against the rest
- Instead vs IndeedIndeed alternatives
- Instead vs TotaljobsTotaljobs alternatives
- Instead vs Caterer.comCaterer.com alternatives
- Instead vs ReedReed alternatives
- Instead vs CV-LibraryCV-Library alternatives
- Instead vs Job TodayJob Today alternatives
- Instead vs HarriHarri alternatives
- Instead vs CoopleCoople alternatives
- Instead vs Find a Job (GOV.UK)Find a Job (GOV.UK) alternatives
- Instead vs Recruitment agenciesRecruitment agencies alternatives
Sources
- Indeed: How pricing works (updated 30 Sept 2026), read 5 November 2026.
- Indeed Help: pay per started application, read 5 November 2026.
- Trustpilot reviews of uk.indeed.com, read 5 November 2026.
Prices change and new-customer offers come and go. If a number here is out of date, email hello@instead.work and it’s fixed the same day.